[Date Prev][Date Next]
[Chronological]
[Thread]
[Top]
Re: Have you seen this FUD - IT pros suffer OpenLDAP configuration headaches ?
On 07/02/2014 18:36, Quanah Gibson-Mount wrote:
> --On Friday, February 07, 2014 2:25 PM +0100 Simone Piccardi
> <piccardi@truelite.it> wrote:
>
>> Not to mention that slapd.conf is still far more readable that any
>> slapd.d ldif...
>
> Definitely not. slapd.conf allows people to put things in all sorts of
> random order that slapd "fixes" when it reads in the slapd.conf file.
I never got any problem with it having always used a it in a correct
order with well commented directives. But if ordering is needed not
having it enforced in the file configuration syntax is a design defect
of slapd, not a shortcoming of using a text file for configuration.
> cn=config enforces correct ordering, so with cn=config you can tell
> exactly what is happening, where it can be a muddled mess with slapd.conf.
>
Using apache, postfix, bind, and so on I usually know quite well what is
happening, just having a text configuration file. And I can use a
generic text editor to modify it, and I don't need to feed the
configuration to the program using some dedicated tool or talking the
specific protocol they are serving.
I agree that the current slapd.conf has lot problems and is prone to
abuse, and if you tell me that rewriting it in a saner way or simply
mantaining it is too much a burden for developers, I will not raise any
further objection.
But this does not change the fact that slapd.conf is far more readable
than a cn=config ldif file, were the use of LDIF syntax force the use of
that ugly curly brace index prefix to order things, and make visible
irrelevant (for the sake of configuration) informations like entryCSN,
createTimestamp, and the like.
Perhaps I'm just getting old, but I still prefer the traditional Unix
way to configure services, by the simple use of human (almost) readable
text configuration files.
Regards
Simone
--
Simone Piccardi - KeyID:2A972F9D - JabberID:piccardi@truelite.it
http://piccardi.gnulinux.it - http://www.fountainpen.it
Prima ti ignorano, poi ti deridono, poi ti combattono. Poi vinci.
M. K. Ghandi