Re: (ITS#7090) back-mdb produces wrong slapcat output

[michael@stroeder.com]

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------000109050706000504040005
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Howard Chu wrote:
> One crucial step in isolating the problem would be to determine if the error
> actually occurs during slapadd or slapcat.

I revise my statement that data looks ok via LDAP. Messing up the data seems
to happen during slapadd if the LDIF is not in tree order (as already
suspected in a former posting which was not read I guess).

Try to slapadd data1.ldif and data2.ldif in the tar.gz attached. data2.ldif is
in tree order while in data1.ldif subordinate entries come before their
superior entries (which is what slapcat sometimes produce).

These entries

dn: ou=Groups,ou=schulung,dc=stroeder,dc=local
objectClass: organizationalUnit
ou: Groups

dn: cn=slapd-1,ou=Systemkonten,ou=schulung,dc=stroeder,dc=local
cn: slapd-1
objectClass: applicationProcess
objectClass: simpleSecurityObject
userPassword: pw_slapd1

get mixed into that:

dn: ou=Groups,ou=schulung,dc=stroeder,dc=local
cn: slapd-1
hasSubordinates: TRUE
objectClass: applicationProcess
objectClass: simpleSecurityObject
userPassword: pw_slapd1

> Bug-hunting takes systematic, methodical testing. You can't just go changing
> revisions willy-nilly.

You don't have to teach me anything in the testing field.

Again: Your arrogant attitude does not help at all. It solely frustrates
people who are trying to help even if they don't have much spare time left.

Get real. How many people do you think are really testing such a wide range of
OpenLDAP functionality like me? How many people you expect to thoroughly test
back-mdb within the next six months even if released in 2.4.27? How many
people do you expect to really dive into such problems? Most people will just
use another backend or another LDAP server.

Ciao, Michael.

--------------000109050706000504040005
Content-Type: application/x-gzip;
 name="openldap-testbed-its7090.tar.gz"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename="openldap-testbed-its7090.tar.gz"
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--------------000109050706000504040005--